Bethel softball mercy-rules Trinity Christian 15-2, splitting doubleheader

by | Feb 20, 2025 | Bethel University, RRSN News, Softball

PALOS HEIGHTS, Ill.– The Bethel Pilots (1-3), faced the Trinity Christian Trolls (1-3) as they split the first season’s doubleheader in the Aurora Dome on Wednesday. The Pilots split the day with a 4-3 loss in game one, then mercy-ruled the Trolls 15-2 in the second match of the afternoon.
GAME ONE
At the top of the first, Jordan Markley walked to get the Pilots’ first runner on base. Maddy Shaw smacked a home run to right center, bringing in both her and Jordan Markley to score two runs.
In the top of the third, Jordan Markley doubled to left center. Kate Cooper followed with a single up the middle, allowing Markley to score on the opponent’s throwing error. The Pilots led 3-0, holding Trinity Christian to only one hit until the bottom of the seventh.
After Natalee McNeil struck out a batter, Bethel secured two outs and was one out away from securing a win. McNeil walked two batters to load the bases, then recorded four RBIs off of two singles to win the game 4-3.
McNeil threw 143 pitches for a complete game (6.2 innings), striking out five batters, walked six batters, and gave up four earned ones.
GAME TWO
The Pilots scored a run at the top of the first to initiate their aggressive scoring. Forys walked to get on base, advancing to second after a bunt by Jordan Markley. Maddy Shaw brought Markley in with a double down the left-field line.
At the top of the second, the Pilots totaled four hits and scored five runs. The Trolls walked Paxton Baker and Sonia Yoder, who both hit season highs for runs scored in a single game (two and three runs respectively).
Baker and Yoder took advantage of a wild pitch, each advancing to the next base.
Morgan Blubaum hit a single to left field, bringing in Paxton Baker to score the Pilots’ second run (2-1). Bethel ended the second inning up 6-1 over the Trolls.
In the bottom of the second, McNeil struck out two batters back to back, holding the Trolls to their lone run.
The Bethel beating persisted at the top of the third inning as the Pilots accumulated four more runs. Hannah Goldsborough hit a double to center field to get Bethel on base. Shelby White entered the game to pitch run for Goldsborough. White scored a run (7-1) following Jordan Markley’s single through the left side.
At the top of the fourth inning, Paxton Baker initiated Bethel’s hitting with a double down the left field line. Baker scored following Hannah Goldsborough’s double to left center (11-1).
The Pilot defense only gave up one additional run in the bottom of the fourth, to secure the mercy rule 15-2 in the bottom of the fifth.
Haylee Allen held down the circle for 1.2 innings, as she threw 63 pitches, posted two strikeouts, and yielded one earned run.
Harmony Looney (1-0) earned the win after throwing 2.2 innings, as she threw a total of six pitches, recorded three strikeouts, and gave up one earned run.
Cassidy Ostema closed the door in the fifth in one pitch.
NEXT TIME OUT
The Pilots will travel to Viera, Florida, to compete in the Space Coast Spring Games series during spring break. The Pilots will face St. Thomas University at 4:45 p.m. on Friday, Feb. 28, in the USSSA Space Coast Complex to kick off the series.
For more information about Bethel Pilots Athletics, check out bupilots.com or follow us on Instagram, Facebook, X, and YouTube by searching @bupilots or using the hashtag #AnchorUp for updates on all 28 Bethel Pilots sports.

Related Stories

MATT’S MATCHUPS 2025-26 HOOPS – WEEK NINE

More progress was made as I went 14-3 (82 percent) last week. My overall record is now 117-41, which has me at 74 percent for the season. TUESDAY Elkhart (5-6) at Michigan City (8-5): The Wolves roared past Elkhart, 66-61, a year ago. Alonzo Newbern’s four points were...

IWU spoils senior day for Peciulis and No.3 Pilots

Bethel Athletics celebrated senior Alonas Peciulis on Saturday afternoon in the Gates Gymnasium for his contributions to the Bethel Men's Basketball Program.  In his four years as a Bethel Pilot, Peciulis competed in the 2025 NAIA...

2025-26 IBCA BOYS’ BASKETBALL POLL – JANUARY 18, 2026

Rank School Total Points Record 1st Place Votes 1 Fishers 439 14-0 21 2 Crown Point 417 12-0 1 3 Plainfield 375 14-1   4 Silver Creek 364 16-1   5 Lawrence North 356 14-1   6 Carmel 329 10-1   7 Pike 308 12-3   8 Mt. Vernon (Fortville) 297...

SOME ENCOURAGING SIGNS FOR IRISH SKATERS IN 6-3 LOSS AT PENN STATE

By John Fineran For 15 seconds Saturday night in its 6-3 Big Ten hockey loss at No. 8 Penn State, there was a very encouraging light at the end of the very long season tunnel for beleaguered Notre Dame and its first-year head coach Brock Sheahan. Though the setback...

PENALTIES, HOT PENN STATE GOALIE KEEP IRISH WINLESS IN BIG TEN IN 4-1 LOSS

By John Fineran Notre Dame’s hockey team wasn’t its own worst enemy Friday night, but the Irish were close. They just couldn’t stay out of the penalty box once again and then couldn’t solve No. 8 Penn State’s goaltender Josh Fleming. Fleming, a 6-foot-2 freshman from...

Dave Troyer Memorial Scholarship Announced

MISHAWAKA, Ind. – This Saturday, January 17, a special presentation is planned to take place during halftime of the men's basketball game where the No. 3 Bethel Pilots take on No. 11 Indiana Wesleyan University in Gates Gymnasium on Bethel's campus. The game will...

IRISH SKATERS VISIT PENN STATE WITH HOPES OF ENDING 7-GAME SKID

By John Fineran WHO: Notre Dame Fighting Irish (4-15-1, 0-10-0 Big Ten for 1 point) vs. Penn State Nittany Lions (14-6-0, 6-4-0 Big Ten for 19 points). WHEN: Friday at 7 p.m. and Saturday at 8 p.m. WHERE: Pegula Ice Arena (6,014), State College, Pa....