Bethel Softball upsets No. 19 Saint Thomas in doubleheader split

by | Mar 1, 2025 | Bethel University, College Sports, Crossroads League, Headlines, NAIA, Softball

VIERA, Fla. —The Bethel Pilots (2-4) fell to Keiser University (12-4) 8-2 on Friday. In their second matchup of the day, Bethel triumphed over No. 19 St. Thomas University (11-1) 2-1.

Jordan Markley totaled three hits and scored one run for the Pilots, and Madison Shaw recorded two runs scored and two hits.

GAME 1

The Bethel Pilots struggled at the top of the first, posting three consecutive outs.

Alyssa Forys lined out to left field. Jordan Markley was thrown out at second by the right fielder following a single, and Madison Shaw grounded out to the shortstop.

Natalee McNeil walked the first Keiser batter before striking out the next one looking. McNeil proceeded to give up three hits as Keiser led at the bottom of the first 2-0.

In the top of the second, Hannah Goldsborough was the first Pilot to get on base with a single-to-center field.

Paxton Baker hit the ball to shortstop, who threw Hannah Goldsborough out at second base.

Harmony Looney grounded out to third to conclude the inning.

In the bottom of the second, Keiser’s first batter flew out to center fielder Jordan Markley. The second batter for Keiser grounded out to Bethel’s Harmony Looney at third.

Natalee McNeil (0-3) got the start for the Pilots for 2.1 innings of work allowing six hits, six runs (five earned), walking three, and striking out one.

Ryen Clair entered in the third inning and closed the game in 3.2 innings allowing four hits, two runs (one earned), and walked one batter.

GAME 2

The Pilots struck in the top of the first, with Alyssa Forys leading off with a single to left field, Jordan Markley drawing a walk, and Maddy Shaw reaching on a fielder’s choice to short to set up runners on first and second.

Kate Cooper ripped it to third and scored Shaw from a fielder’s choice that resulted in Markley being put out at third.

Saint Thomas tied the game in the bottom of the second with an RBI single to left, but Bethel answered in the top of the seventh from an error by the third baseman to result in the first Pilot victory over an NAIA Top 25 opponent since No. 16 Marian at Gardner Field on May 17, 2022, 5-2.

The Pilots are now 1-1 against Saint Thomas with their first-ever meeting on March 1, 2016, where BU lost 12-3 in Clermont, Fla.

Bethel continues the USSSA Space Coast Games on Monday, March 1, with New College of Florida at 10 a.m. and Hannibal-LaGrange at 12:15 p.m.

Related Stories

Big Ten Weekly Women’s Basketball Central – Jan. 20-26

Big Ten Weekly Women's Basketball Central - Jan. 20-26 Big Ten. Big News. • Half of the Big Ten’s 16 games will be featured on national platforms this week, while the remaining games will be streamed live on B1G+ (visit bigtenplus.com for more information). A top-15...

Big Ten Weekly Men’s Basketball Central – January 20-26

Big Ten Weekly Men's Basketball Central - January 20-26 Big Ten. Big News. Entering this week’s action, every Big Ten team has played at least seven conference games so far. The only remaining unbeaten squads in league play were Purdue (7-0) and Nebraska (7-0). For...

Indiana Recognized as Recipient of Iconic NFF MacArthur Bowl

  The Hoosiers claim the trophy for the first time in school history, concluding their historic season with a dramatic 27-21 win over Miami (FL) in the CFP National Championship. IRVING, TEXAS (Jan. 20, 2026) - The National Football Foundation (NFF) & College...

2026 COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYOFF NATIONAL CHAMPIONS NEWS CONFERENCE

Click the links below to download a transcript from the 2026 College Football Playoff National Champions News Conference, featuring Indiana head coach Curt Cignetti, Offensive Player of the Game QB Fernando Mendoza, Defensive Player of the Game DL Mikail Kamara, OL...

No.1 IU outlasts Miami to win the National Championship

Perfection Punctuates National Title   MIAMI -- Sometimes nice guys do finish first. They do so because they care, because they push, because they do what’s expected and then more, on the field and away from spotlights and glory. And then they make history. On...

Maryland, Nebraska, and Wisconsin Garner Men’s Basketball Weekly Honors

Maryland, Nebraska, and Wisconsin Garner Men’s Basketball Weekly Honors Terrapins’ Coit, Badgers’ Blackwell, and Huskers’ Frager earn Big Ten weekly accolades Co-Player of the Week Diggy Coit, Maryland G –Grad. – 5-11 – Columbus, N.J. - Scotland (Pa.) Campus Sports •...

Iowa Collects Big Ten Weekly Women’s Basketball Honors

Iowa Collects Big Ten Weekly Women’s Basketball Honors Hawkeyes’ Stuelke and Deal earn weekly awards Player of the Week Hannah Stuelke, Iowa Sr. – Forward – Cedar Rapids, Iowa – Cedar Rapids Washington • Paced the Hawkeyes with 22 points on 10-for-14 shooting with...

2025 IFCA Good Works Team Announced

2025 IFCA Good Works Team The Indiana Football Coaches Association (IFCA) is proud to recognize service, leadership, and character through the 2025 IFCA Good Works Team Award. This honor was created to celebrate players, managers, and teams who have gone above and...

Crossroads League Announces Athletes of the Week | January 12-18

Crossroads League Announces Athletes of the Week | January 12-18 JACKSON, Mich. – The Crossroads League Athletes of the Week were announced on Monday, recognizing the league’s top individual performances from January 12 through 18. Sports Information Directors from...

Holy Cross men fall at home to Viterbo, 64-53

The Holy Cross men's basketball team battled through a tightly contested matchup but ultimately fell 64–53 to Viterbo on Saturday afternoon at McKenna Arena The game remained close throughout, with both teams trading defensive stops and struggling...