Olivia Nickerson Breaks Bethel Record for Single Game Triples in win at Ave Maria

by | Dec 17, 2025 | Basketball, Bethel University, College Sports, Headlines, NAIA

Olivia Nickerson Breaks Bethel Record for Single Game Triples in win at Ave Maria

AVE MARIA, Fla. — The Bethel Pilots (9-4) defeated the Ave Maria Gyrenes (4-5) 89-62 on Tuesday evening for the first time in program history at the Tom Golisano Fieldhouse.

Sophomore Olivia Nickerson shattered the record for threes made in a single game (11). The previous record holders were Maci Heimlich (2019), Madison Schrock (2015), and Joy Ketelsen (2001) who stood at a three-way tie with eight threes each. Additionally, Nickerson tied Natalie Young (2006) for points scored in a single game (39).

Izzy Nooe recorded a season high of 16 points, shooting 85 percent from the field.

Isabel Scales led the team in rebounds with eight (4-4), while Mariah Claywell led the team in assists (seven).

Bethel stayed consistent throughout the entirety of the matchup, making 100 percent of their shots at the line (9-9), shooting 53 percent from the field, and all while never dropping the lead.

The Pilots had their greatest showing in the second quarter, racking up two separate 11 point runs while totaling 30 points in the quarter.

Head Coach Scott Polsgrove shared, “What a great way to put an exclamation point on our Florida trip. Really proud of the way we defended and it was fun to watch a special performance by Olivia Nickerson.”

The Pilots will next face Siena Heights University (4-4) on Wed, Dec. 31. Tip-off is set for 1 PM at the Siena Heights Fieldhouse.

Related Stories

Dave Troyer Memorial Scholarship Announced

MISHAWAKA, Ind. – This Saturday, January 17, a special presentation is planned to take place during halftime of the men's basketball game where the No. 3 Bethel Pilots take on No. 11 Indiana Wesleyan University in Gates Gymnasium on Bethel's campus. The game will...

Phelps Paces Titans in Win

Phelps Paces Titans in Win ELGIN, Ill. – An offensive showcase was displayed on Thursday night, as IU South Bend took down Judson 79-61 on the road to improve to 12-5 overall and 7-2 in CCAC play. The Titans never trailed, using a fast start and steady execution on...

IRISH SKATERS VISIT PENN STATE WITH HOPES OF ENDING 7-GAME SKID

By John Fineran WHO: Notre Dame Fighting Irish (4-15-1, 0-10-0 Big Ten for 1 point) vs. Penn State Nittany Lions (14-6-0, 6-4-0 Big Ten for 19 points). WHEN: Friday at 7 p.m. and Saturday at 8 p.m. WHERE: Pegula Ice Arena (6,014), State College, Pa....

Holy Cross WBB grinds our 43-39 at home over Saint Xavier

The Holy Cross women's basketball team earned a 43–39 home victory over Saint Xavier on Wednesday night at McKenna Arena, using a strong second-half push and key bench contributions to secure the conference matchup win. After a slow start offensively, Holy Cross...

Holy Cross MBB rolls past Saint Xavier, 83-69

It was a night to remember at McKenna Arena as the Holy Cross men's basketball team delivered an impressive 83–69 victory over Saint Xavier, highlighted by Joey Garwood reaching the 1,000-point milestone in his collegiate career. The game opened as a back-and-forth...

No.1 Grace races past No.3 Pilots

WINONA LAKE, Ind.---On Wednesday evening, the No. 3 Bethel Pilots (16-2, 6-2) fell 99-81 to the No. 1 Grace College Lancers (18-0, 8-0) in the Manahan OCC.  Jameir Jefferson, last week's Crossroads League Defender of the Week, totaled 18 points and 11 rebounds...

Bethel Women’s basketball holds off Grace

WINONA LAKE, Ind. ---The Bethel Pilots (13-5, 4-4) picked up their third consecutive win over the Grace College Lancers (9-9, 1-7) with a 97-95 victory in the Manahan OCC on Wednesday evening. Jazmyn Smith showcased a double-double with 26 points, her highest scoring...

IUSB Men’s Basketball Home Win Moves Streak to 11

Home Win Moves Streak to 11 SOUTH BEND — IU South Bend continued its dominant stretch on a wintery Wednesday night, rolling past Judson 82-55 inside the Student Activities Center to extend its winning streak to 11 games. From the opening minutes, the Titans set the...

Hoosiers WBB Fall To Washington

Hoosiers Fall To Washington BLOOMINGTON, Ind. – Indiana women’s basketball couldn’t overcome a hot shooting night by Washington as it fell 82-63 on Wednesday night at Simon Skjodt Assembly Hall. KEY MOMENTS • Freshman forward Maya Makalusky and senior guard Shay...