Valpo Football Falls at Nationally-Ranked Presbyterian

by | Nov 1, 2025 | College Sports, Football Blogs, Headlines

Valpo Football Falls at Nationally-Ranked Presbyterian

The Valparaiso University football team dropped Saturday’s game to No. 25/22 Presbyterian 43-14 at Bailey Memorial Stadium in Clinton, S.C. Mark Johnson (Nashville, Tenn. / Lipscomb) had two defensive takeaways to provide a Beacon bright spot, while quarterback Rowan Keefe (Park Ridge, Ill. / Maine South) passed for a career-high 224 yards.

 

How It Happened

  • The Valpo defense battled on the opening drive of the game, but the Blue Hose went 68 yards on 11 plays in 5:37 to reach the end zone first. Darriel Harper scored from seven yards out on a reverse to make it 7-0 with 9:18 on the first-quarter clock.
  • After the offense went three-and-out, the Valpo defense forced a three-and-out on the second PC drive.
  • Quarterback Collin Hurst was on target through PC’s third drive, eventually finding Kibby for a 17-yard touchdown.
  • The next Presbyterian drive went backward eight yards, with the Valpo defense doing a great job led by a sack from Isaiah Fowler (Gary, Ind. / Chesterton) and De’Andre Wilborn (Chicago, Ill. / Westinghouse).
  • The Beacons moved the ball some on their next drive by recording the team’s first first down of the day, then a big punt from Nate Hillenburg (Indianapolis, Ind. / Cathedral [Cornell]) helped flip the field.
  • With 3:26 left in the second quarter, Presbyterian settled for a 27-yard field goal after the Valpo defense did not break at the end of the possession. Wyatt Little (Fort Wayne, Ind. / Homestead), Micah Markley (West Chesterton, Ohio / Lakota West) and Anthony Feltrinelli (Westfield, Ind. / Westfield) were all in the area of a stop for a loss of two on third-and-seven.
  • The Beacons lost a fumble for their first turnover of the game, then the Blue Hose scored on a trick play with their QB Hurst on a receiving end of a 12-yard TD to make it 23-0 with 2:31 left in the opening half.
  • The Blue Hose were in the redzone and had a chance for more points prior to half, but a huge defensive play by Mark Johnson (Nashville, Tenn. / Lipscomb) helped Valpo come up with a takeaway at the Valpo 15 as he stripped the ball and then landed on it, forcing and recovering the fumble, keeping the halftime deficit at 23.
  • The Beacons started the second half with their longest offensive play of the day to that point, as Micah Mackay (Zionsville, Ind. / Lutheran) took off for a big run after the catch as part of a 49-yard reception to the PC 26.
  • The opening drive of the second half ended with a missed field goal. The Blue Hose went 80 yards on a 14-play, 6:42 drive that ended with a great throw from Hurst despite being under heavy pressure, complete to Kibby for an 18-yard score to make it 30-0.
  • Johnson picked up his second takeaway of the day for the Valpo defense with 2:30 left in the first half. He picked off a pass at the Valpo 19 and returned it 38 yards to the PC 43.
  • That takeaway set up a Valpo touchdown drive that saw Keefe complete a pair of key passes, one to Ryan Ricketti (Rocky River, Ohio / Rocky River) and another to Jay Melchiori (Marengo, Ohio / Highland [Marietta]), the second of which went for a touchdown to make it 30-7.
  • Presbyterian scored twice more to build up the lead to 43-7. Wilborn blocked a PAT after one of the Blue Hose touchdowns.
  • Mackay took a handoff for his first carry and bulldozed into the endzone for a 2-yard touchdown to make it 43-14, which stood as the final. Keefe completed passes to a variety of receivers on that drive including a 17 yarder to Mackay. That drive went 82 yards on 13 plays in 7:13.

 

Inside the Game

  • Mackay’s TD was not only his first career rushing score, but it was his first career rushing attempt period. It marked his third career touchdown overall, one receiving, one on a return and one rushing.
  • Melchiori had his 10th career receiving TD and his first in a Valpo uniform.
  • Melchiori and Ricketti had four grabs apiece, with Melchiori leading the team with 71 receiving yards.
  • Redshirt senior Liam Shepherd (Valparaiso, Ind. / Valparaiso [Ball State]) entered the game as the placekicker and made a pair of PATs.
  • Feltrinelli racked up 13 tackles, his second highest total of the season and highest since 14 vs. Adrian.
  • Redshirt sophomore Connor Cervantes (Griffith, Ind. / Griffith) equaled a career high set against Adrian with seven tackles. Johnson, Nic Lendino (Naperville, Ill. / Neuqua Valley) and Jason Salman (Pittsburgh, Pa. / Thomas Jefferson [Marietta]) chipped in six apiece.
  • Johnson’s interception was the second of his career, both this season. His forced fumble and fumble recovery were both career firsts.
  • Keefe went 17-of-26 through the air for a career-high 224 yards and a touchdown including a solid second half.
  • The 224 passing yards marked the team’s single-season season high. Eight different players caught passes for the Beacons.
  • Hillenburg’s 59-yard punt was a season long, eclipsing his previous best of 56. His career long of 62 came last season while playing for Cornell.
  • Wilborn’s blocked kick was the first of his career and the team’s third of the season.

 

Up Next

Valpo (1-8, 0-5 PFL) will host San Diego next week at noon on Saturday.

Related Content

Nov 27 2025

AFTER A DAY OF THANKSGIVING, IT’S TIME TO RENEW HOCKEY’S ‘HOLY WAR’

AFTER A DAY OF THANKSGIVING, IT’S TIME TO RENEW HOCKEY’S ‘HOLY WAR’ By John Fineran Whenever Notre Dame and Boston College meet in any athletic competition, it’s known...
Nov 27 2025

THE 2025 INDIANA FOOTBALL DIGEST’S TOP GAMES – STATE FINALS

  CLASS 1A PIONEER (13-1) VS. SOUTH PUTNAM (12-2) KICKOFF: 11 a.m. EST, Friday, Lucas Oil Stadium. COACHES: Adam Berry, 101-26 in 10th season at Pioneer. Chuck...
Nov 27 2025

FIRED-UP COLES (BROWN AND KNUBLE) HELP IRISH END SKID WITH 5-4 PRE-THANKSGIVING VICTORY AT MERRIMACK

FIRED-UP COLES (BROWN AND KNUBLE) HELP IRISH END SKID WITH 5-4 PRE-THANKSGIVING VICTORY AT MERRIMACK   By John Fineran   Late Wednesday afternoon as he skated...
Nov 27 2025

VU Men’s Basketball Falls to Southern Indiana

Men’s Basketball Falls to Southern Indiana The Valparaiso University men’s basketball team saw a three-game winning streak come to an end on Wednesday afternoon with a...
Nov 27 2025

VU Women’s Basketball Drop Opener of CSU Invitational to Radford

Beacons Drop Opener of CSU Invitational to Radford   The Valpo women’s basketball team outscored Radford over the final three quarters of its opener at the CSU...