Valpo University WBB Falls in Overtime to Milwaukee

by | Nov 17, 2025 | Basketball Blogs, College Sports, Headlines

Beacons Fall in Overtime to Milwaukee

The Valpo women’s basketball team looked to be on the verge of its first victory of the season at the ARC Sunday afternoon against Milwaukee after Mikayla Huffine (Rockford, Ill./Rockford Lutheran [Quincy/Iowa Western C.C.]) hit a pair of free throws with 3.4 seconds to play to give the Beacons the lead, but the visiting Panthers split a pair of foul shots with 0.6 seconds remaining in regulation to send the game to overtime and came out 72-67 victors in the extra session.

How It Happened

–          Milwaukee pushed what was a three-point lead with 10 minutes to play to five twice in the fourth quarter, but both times Valpo responded — the second time by rattling off six straight points, capped by a floater from Autumn Dibb (Muskego, Wis./Muskego) to put the Beacons in front 53-52 with 4:20 to play.

–          The Panthers responded to regain the lead on their next possession and pushed their lead to three points twice in the final two minutes. Valpo came back immediately with a bucket both times, as first Mor Shabtai (Tel Aviv, Israel/Tichonet) and then Dibb answered, the latter making it a 59-58 Milwaukee lead with 41 seconds remaining.

–          The Beacons got a stop on the defensive end, and after taking a timeout to advance the ball, put the ball in the hands of Huffine. The senior put her head down, got fouled while shooting with 3.4 seconds to go and calmly connected on both to make it 60-59 Beacons.

–          After the Panthers advanced the ball with a timeout, the Beacons were called for a shooting foul with 0.6 seconds remaining. Grace Lomen knocked down the first to tie the game, but came up short on the second to send the game to overtime.

–          It took nearly half the extra period to knock the lid off the baskets, but after Milwaukee knocked down a 3-pointer to open the scoring, Shabtai responded with a triple of her own to tie things up at 63-63 with 2:18 to go in overtime.

–          The Panthers followed with a score on the ensuing possession to take the lead for good. Kylie Waytashek (Royalton, Minn./Royalton) converted a layup with 54 seconds remaining to make it a one-point game, but Milwaukee hit two free throws on its next trip and the Beacons missed a pair of chances near the rim as the Panthers closed it out.

–          Milwaukee opened the game on an 8-0 run over the first 3:34 of action before Valpo gave up just two points over a stretch of four-plus minutes to close back to a one-possession game. The Panthers led 14-10 at the end of the opening quarter.

–          Valpo’s defense recorded five straight stops to start the second quarter to help open the period on an 8-0 run, as Fiona Connolly (South Burlington, Vt./Brewster Academy [La Salle]) hit a 3-pointer and Shabtai scored five points to give Valpo an 18-14 lead with 7:17 to play in the half.

–          Milwaukee scored seven straight to regain the lead in a back-and-forth period which featured five lead changes and three ties. When the dust settled, a hook shot inside of 30 seconds remaining in the half from Milana Nenadic (Kitchener, Ontario/Cameron Heights [Idaho State/Maine]) had the Beacons in front 31-29 at halftime.

–          The third quarter was another back-and-forth stanza with five ties and five lead changes. Neither squad led by more than one possession over the final five minutes of the period, with Milwaukee eventually carrying a 48-45 lead into the fourth quarter.

 

Inside the Game

–          Sunday’s game was Valpo’s home opener — the Beacons will be away from home for their next four games, not returning home to the ARC until Dec. 7.

–          Valpo took Milwaukee to overtime after the last six meetings in the series had all been double-digit wins for the Panthers.

–          The Beacons have dropped each of their last four games to go to overtime — the program’s last overtime win came at Evansville in February 2022.

–          A balanced Beacon offense was led by a strong effort off the bench from Allia von Schlegell (Downers Grove, Ill./Nazareth). The freshman set season highs with 15 points, five rebounds and four assists. The MVC leader in 3-point percentage entering the game, von Schlegell hit 3-of-7 from deep on Sunday.

–          Valpo’s second-leading scorer also came off the bench, as Kamryn Winch (Bonne Terre, Mo./North County [Maryville]) recorded career bests with 12 points and 12 rebounds, securing her first collegiate double-double.

–          The Beacons’ bench outscored Milwaukee’s by a 36-16 count.

–          Shabtai scored in double figures for the first time in her collegiate career, finishing with 11 points to surpass her previous high of eight points — accomplished twice in the first three games this season.

–          Nenadic scored in double figures for the second straight game, rounding out the quartet of Beacons in double digits as she tallied 10 points.

–          Dibb notched seven points and seven rebounds, both season highs.

–          Valpo won the battle of the boards for the first time this season, 44-42.

–          The Beacons handed out a season-best 18 assists on 23 made baskets and had a positive assist/turnover ratio, committing just 17 turnovers. Valpo’s turnover total dropped for the third straight game.

 

Next Up

Valpo (0-4) returns to the road Friday night, as the Beacons trek to Vermillion, S.D. to play at South Dakota at 7 p.m.

Related Stories

Dave Troyer Memorial Scholarship Announced

MISHAWAKA, Ind. – This Saturday, January 17, a special presentation is planned to take place during halftime of the men's basketball game where the No. 3 Bethel Pilots take on No. 11 Indiana Wesleyan University in Gates Gymnasium on Bethel's campus. The game will...

Phelps Paces Titans in Win

Phelps Paces Titans in Win ELGIN, Ill. – An offensive showcase was displayed on Thursday night, as IU South Bend took down Judson 79-61 on the road to improve to 12-5 overall and 7-2 in CCAC play. The Titans never trailed, using a fast start and steady execution on...

IRISH SKATERS VISIT PENN STATE WITH HOPES OF ENDING 7-GAME SKID

By John Fineran WHO: Notre Dame Fighting Irish (4-15-1, 0-10-0 Big Ten for 1 point) vs. Penn State Nittany Lions (14-6-0, 6-4-0 Big Ten for 19 points). WHEN: Friday at 7 p.m. and Saturday at 8 p.m. WHERE: Pegula Ice Arena (6,014), State College, Pa....

Holy Cross WBB grinds our 43-39 at home over Saint Xavier

The Holy Cross women's basketball team earned a 43–39 home victory over Saint Xavier on Wednesday night at McKenna Arena, using a strong second-half push and key bench contributions to secure the conference matchup win. After a slow start offensively, Holy Cross...

Holy Cross MBB rolls past Saint Xavier, 83-69

It was a night to remember at McKenna Arena as the Holy Cross men's basketball team delivered an impressive 83–69 victory over Saint Xavier, highlighted by Joey Garwood reaching the 1,000-point milestone in his collegiate career. The game opened as a back-and-forth...

No.1 Grace races past No.3 Pilots

WINONA LAKE, Ind.---On Wednesday evening, the No. 3 Bethel Pilots (16-2, 6-2) fell 99-81 to the No. 1 Grace College Lancers (18-0, 8-0) in the Manahan OCC.  Jameir Jefferson, last week's Crossroads League Defender of the Week, totaled 18 points and 11 rebounds...

Bethel Women’s basketball holds off Grace

WINONA LAKE, Ind. ---The Bethel Pilots (13-5, 4-4) picked up their third consecutive win over the Grace College Lancers (9-9, 1-7) with a 97-95 victory in the Manahan OCC on Wednesday evening. Jazmyn Smith showcased a double-double with 26 points, her highest scoring...

IUSB Men’s Basketball Home Win Moves Streak to 11

Home Win Moves Streak to 11 SOUTH BEND — IU South Bend continued its dominant stretch on a wintery Wednesday night, rolling past Judson 82-55 inside the Student Activities Center to extend its winning streak to 11 games. From the opening minutes, the Titans set the...

Hoosiers WBB Fall To Washington

Hoosiers Fall To Washington BLOOMINGTON, Ind. – Indiana women’s basketball couldn’t overcome a hot shooting night by Washington as it fell 82-63 on Wednesday night at Simon Skjodt Assembly Hall. KEY MOMENTS • Freshman forward Maya Makalusky and senior guard Shay...